International Relations Researches

International Relations Researches

US Unilateralism and the Legitimacy Crisis of the WTO Dispute Settlement System

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Ph.D. Student, Department of Public International Law, Kish International Campus, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
2 Corresponding Author, Professor of Department of Public and International Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
3 Associate Professor of International Law, Department of Public Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Tehran University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
10.22034/irr.2026.606069.2933
Abstract
The World Trade Organization (WTO) dispute settlement system is essential for ensuring compliance with multilateral trade rules and maintaining stability and predictability in international trade. However, the United States’ opposition to the Appellate Body and its continued blocking of new appointments led to the suspension of its operations in December 2019, triggering a major institutional crisis. This study examines the role of U.S. unilateralism in intensifying the crisis and analyzes the consequences of the Appellate Body impasse and the Multi-Party Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement (MPIA). The research adopts a descriptive-analytical method based on WTO legal instruments, official U.S. positions, and relevant academic studies. The findings indicate that U.S. objections extended beyond dispute adjudication procedures to concerns regarding interpretive authority, the creation of new obligations through judicial interpretation, the status of previous rulings, and compliance with procedural deadlines. Blocking appointments rendered appellate review inoperative and contributed to the emergence of “appeals into the void,” undermining the enforceability of dispute settlement decisions and confidence in the system. In response, the MPIA was established under Article 25 of the Dispute Settlement Understanding (DSU), allowing participating members to preserve appellate review through arbitration. Nevertheless, its limited participation and interim nature prevent it from fully replacing a universal appellate mechanism. The study concludes that resolving the crisis requires reforming the appointment process, clarifying the scope of appellate jurisdiction, and establishing a sustainable multilateral mechanism capable of preventing institutional paralysis and strengthening the effectiveness and predictability of WTO dispute settlement
Keywords

Annisa, I. B. N. (2022). The recent crisis of the WTO Appellate Body: Is the WTO’s reform a solution? Yustisia, 11(3), 1–18.
Chang-fa, L., Nakagawa, J., & Tsai-Fang, C. (2019). The Appellate Body of the WTO and Its Reform. Tokyo: Springer.
Chow, D. C. K., & Schoenbaum, T. J. (2017). International trade law: Problems, cases, and materials (3rd ed.). West Academic Publishing.
Condon, B. J. (2018). Captain America and the tarnishing of the crown: The feud between the WTO Appellate Body and the USA. Journal of World Trade, 52(6), 1001–1030.
Fiorini, M., Hoekman, B. M., Mavroidis, P. C., Saluste, M., & Wolfe, R. (2020). WTO dispute settlement and the Appellate Body crisis: Insider perceptions and members’ revealed preferences. Journal of World Trade, 54(5), 667–698. https://doi.org/10.54648/TRAD2020029
Gao, H. S. (2021). Finding a rule-based solution to the Appellate Body crisis: Looking beyond the multiparty interim appeal arbitration arrangement. Journal of International Economic Law, 24(3), 803–825.
Gao, Henry. (2021). Finding a rule-based solution to the Appellate Body crisis: Looking beyond the Multiparty Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement. Journal of International Economic Law, 24(3), 534–550. https://doi.org/10.1093/jiel/jgab031
Hoekman, Bernard M., & Mavroidis, Petros C. (2020). To AB or not to AB? Dispute settlement in WTO reform. Journal of International Economic Law, 23(3), 1–20. https://doi.org/10.1093/jiel/jgaa020
Hogan, Statement by Commissioner Phil at Informal WTO Ministerial, Davos[EB/OL].[2022-08-20]. https://ec.europa.eu/commission/commissioners/2019-2024/hogan/announcements/statement-commissionerphil-hogan-informal-wto-ministerial-davos_en
Hopewell, Kristen. (2025). Unravelling of the trade legal order: Enforcement, defection and the crisis of the WTO dispute settlement system. International Affairs, 101(3), 1103–1117. https://doi.org/10.1093/ia/iiaf055
Johnson, K. (2019). “How Trump May Finally Kill the WTO.” Foreign Policy. Available at: https://www.foreignpolicy.com/2019/12/09/trump-may-kill-wto-finally-appellate-body-world-trade-organization/
Lighthizer, Robert E. (2020). Report on the Appellate Body of the World Trade Organization. Office of the United States Trade Representative. Available at: https://ustr.gov/sites/default/files/Report_on_the_Appellate_Body_of_the_World_Trade_Organization.pdf (accessed September 11, 2021).
Limschoon, B. (2022). The WTO dispute settlement in crisis: When United States’ influence overshadows the rule of law for multilateral trading system. Thammasat Law Journal, 51(3), 1–24.
Malkawi. Bashar H.. "International arbitration mechanisms and the use of arbitration: bypassing the WTO Appellate Body", JURIST, 28 May 2020.
McDougall, R. (2018). The crisis in WTO dispute settlement: Fixing birth defects to restore balance. Journal of World Trade, 52(6), 867–896.
Office of the U.S. Trade Representative (USTR). (2017). The President's 2017 trade policy agenda. https://ustr.gov/sites/default/files/files/reports/2017/AnnualReport/Chapter%201%20The%20President%27s%20Trade%20Policy%20Agenda.pdf
Pahis, Stratos. (2024). Appeals after the Appellate Body. World Trade Review, 23(Special Issue 3), 296–323. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1474745624000041
Pan, Kaijun. (2025). Breaking the impasse of appointing members of the WTO Appellate Body: A perspective from international institutional law. World Trade Review, 24(Special Issue 3), 404–422. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1474745624000648
Pauwelyn, J. (2019). WTO dispute settlement post 2019: What to expect? Journal of International Economic Law, 22(3), 297–321. https://doi.org/10.1093/jiel/jgz024
Pauwelyn, J. (2023). The WTO’s Multi-Party Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement (MPIA): What’s new? World Trade Review, 22(5), 693–701. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1474745623000204
Petersmann, E.-U. (2019). How should WTO members react to their WTO crises? World Trade Review, 18(3), 503–525.
Reinsch, W. A. (2019). Salvaging the World Trade Organization. Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). Available at: https://www.csis.org/analysis/salvaging-world-trade-organization
Schonfeld, B. (2016, September 20). Why the U.S. needs the World Trade Organization. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2016/09/20/would-the-u-s-be-better-off-without-the-wto-not-when-the-wto-guides-98-percent-of-global-trade/
Titievskaia, Jana. (2021). "International Trade Dispute Settlement: WTO Appellate Body Crisis and the Multiparty Interim Appeal Arrangement." European Parliamentary Research Service (EPRS).
Umenze, N. S. (2021). Is the WTO Appellate Body in limbo? The roots of the crisis in the WTO dispute settlement body and the available routes navigating the quagmire. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 24, 1–25. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2021/v24i0a8580
World Trade Organization. (1989). Colombia—Anti-Dumping Duties on Frozen Fries From Belgium, Germany and The Netherlands: Agreed Procedures for Arbitration under Article 25 of the DSU (WT/DS591/3).
World Trade Organization. (1994). Understanding on rules and procedures governing the settlement of disputes. World Trade Organization.
World Trade Organization. (2018, March 23). Request for consultations by the United States: China—Certain measures concerning the protection of intellectual property rights (WTO Doc. WT/DS542/1).
World Trade Organization. (2020). Alternative dispute resolution procedures: Article 25 arbitration and Multi-Party Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement (MPIA). World Trade Organization
World Trade Organization. (2020). Multi-Party Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement pursuant to Article 25 of the DSU. World Trade Organization.
World Trade Organization. (2021, January 15). Waiver from Certain Provisions of the TRIPS Agreement for the Prevention, Containment and Treatment of COVID-19 – Questions by Proponents. IP/C/W/674.
World Trade Organization. (2022, July 6). Multi-Party Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement pursuant to Article 25 of the DSU: Pool of arbitrators (JOB/DSB/1/Add.12/Suppl.8).
World Trade Organization. (2023, March 10). Multi-Party Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement pursuant to Article 25 of the DSU: Japan joins the MPIA (JOB/DSB/1/Add.12/Suppl.9).
Zaccaria, L. (2022). You’re fired! International courts, re-contracting, and the WTO Appellate Body during the Trump presidency. Global Policy, 13(4), 531–543. https://doi.org/10.1111/1758-5899.13032